Editor’s note: This is the fourth and final essay in a week long series for Father’s Day written by papás who are raising bilingual and bicultural children. We hope you’ve enjoyed all of the essays this week. If you missed anything, you can always go to the introductory post for links to the essays and to our awesome giveaway!
Long before our daughter Aylin Carolina was born last October, my wife Deniz and I decided what she wasn’t going to be when she grew up: monolingual. With three languages between us, we knew giving her a chance at being trilingual was the greatest inheritance we could offer her. Not only would this inheritance be impervious to inflation or Wall Street shenanigans, it would also be the sturdiest bridge to her roots.
We certainly realize we’re wide-eyed new parents, who are only eight months into an 18-year race. And never mind that Aylin has yet to turn indecipherable ga-ga goo-goos into coherent words… in any language. Even so, we feel good about our chances. Confident. Perhaps, it’s because we have a few key things going for us.
For starters, Deniz and I are kindred spirits when it comes to having a strong sense of our cultural identity. It’s true that in some ways, we couldn’t be more different. She’s Muslim; I was raised Catholic. She’s of Turkish descent; I’m of Ecuadorian. Her native language is Turkish, mine’s Spanish. Despite our differences, we’re bonded by how much our cultures mean to us. And by being likeminded on something so deeply rooted, we support each other without hesitation. I know, for instance, that I can count on Deniz eventually supporting me and even helping me teach Aylin to dance a San Juanito (folkoric Ecuadorian dance), and Deniz can rest assured she’ll have an ally in teaching Aylin to sing Baris Manco (Turkish folk singer) songs. The same is already true with language. We already keep each other honest by reminding ourselves to speak to Aylin only in Turkish and Spanish.
Another important thing we have going for us: we don’t have to look past our own parents to teach us how to raise bilingual children. They really blazed the trail for us. Deniz’s Turkish parents and my Ecuadorian parents didn’t buy into the big American immigrant fallacy, which suggests that to assimilate you need to somehow shed off your culture and forget the language. As first-generation, hyphenated-Americans, Deniz and I were raised to love, serve, and bleed red, white, and blue, while preserving the rich, textured, multicolored fabrics that also made us Turkish and Ecuadorian, respectively. Even though our English may have carried a slight accent early on, since we both learned our parents’ languages first, we certainly didn’t allow our accents to bound or curtail our patriotism for the land of our birth.
Our parents also staunchly subscribed to a simple but effective method at home, which we plan to adopt: the “no comprendo” method in my case and the “anlamadim” method in Deniz’s. It simply means, “I don’t understand,” which is exactly what we’d hear our parents say if we tried to pull a fast one on them and talk to them in English at home. Although our parents spoke English perfectly and were not hard of hearing, they checked it at the door and stubbornly and consistently turned an “English-only” deaf ear on us. The challenge will be a little more difficult for Deniz and I because, unlike our parents, English comes most naturally for us, and because we communicate with each other in English—yet another reason we’re bent on learning each other’s language.
We’ve read a few books on the subject of raising bilingual children. We recognize this quest has its share of detractors, and it can even present some unintended consequences, such as a delay in children speaking. And we also know the road ahead will require patience and relentlessness. But these are risks and the commitment we’re willing to take on to ensure we do not deny our Aylin of her rightful inheritance. We now completely understand what parents mean when they say they want their kids to be better of than them. We suppose this is a good start towards that end.
Great post! We are doing the same to raise trilingual boys, but with Spanish, German and English. It is amazing how easily they can move between languages. What surprised me is how well their German developed. That is the language they speak with papi. I thought that Spanish would be so much stronger since they are with me more hours in the day and have pre-school teachers that speak to them in Spanish. This has not been the case. My older son in particular loves having a special language with just papi.
Good luck to you. You have a beautiful family.
En mi casa tenemos una experiencia parecida, hasta ahora mis hijos de 7 y 9 años hablan tres lenguas, aunque escriben y leen dos, por lo que falta hacer más enfasis en una de estos lenguajes,, la gran dificultad surge porque nosotros nos comunicamos en inglés y eso es lo que hablamos en casa aunque los niños hablan en cada uno de nuestros lenguajes con cada padre. Estaré pendiente de tu blog para poder resolver mis dudas. Exitos con tu hija. ( Se me olvidaba que de paso en la escuela ven otras dos lenguas diferentes aunque no con gran enfásis – Mandarin y Francés). Sin embargo no han tenido retardo en el habla y los dos son muy buenos escribiendo y comunicando sus ideas.
I, also, am at the very beginning of my journey in raising tri-lingual children (French, Spanish, English), and perhaps have less of a foundation than you and your wife. Nevertheless, I know my husband and I are dedicated to the effort, and your story gives me hope and reassurance. Thanks for the great post!
Mario, Great article. I wish you and Deniz all the best in raising little Miss Aylin to be multilingual and also grounding her in your roots and culture. I’m currently trying to do the same with my three year old son Evan, with my somewhat rusty Spanish. It’s good for us both as he is learning another language and I am relearning my Spanish. Thanks for the wonderful post! Swell
PS: Love the pic of the family!
Amigo, as you can see, you’re not alone. I so appreciate you writing this essay for us and I’m in awe of what you and your wife are doing with your daughter. I agree with you 100% about how this is the best inheritance you can leave her. I feel exactly the same way.
I would love it if you keep us updated as Aylin grows up and starts answering you back in Spanish, Turkish and English! I know it’ll be totally worth it when that happens!
A wonderful story! Thanks for sharing it with us Mario. My husband and I are actually leaving for a 2 week vacation to Quito. My father in law is from there. We are going to a cousin’s wedding. We would also like our bebita to be trilingual, except we are going about it a different route because my husband and I are bilingual. At any rate, suerte!
Dear Mario,
Wonderful article, really loved it. Aylin is lucky to have parents like you and Deniz. Good luck with rasing the little lady. We shall be there to support you, if you need our help.
Love,
Nursel
(Deniz’s mother, Turkish grandma)
Hola mi hijito, me emociono tu escrito, la verdad es que tienes un don que Dios te ha dado en poder expresar escribiendo lo que piensas y sientes y nos sentimos felices de que tanto tu como Deniz hagan enfasis en seguir lo mismo que nosotros les inculcamos, en amar y sentirse orgullosos de sus raices y aunque de pequeños tu y tus hermanos nos hablaban en ingles y nosotros pretendiamos NO entenderlos, de esa manera los forzamos a aprender el español y eso nos hace felices y orgullosos de que nuestros hijos sepan el idioma nuestro y se puedan comunicar con la hermosa y extensa familia que tienen en Ecuador. Asi nuestra muñequita AYLIN tambien gozara del privilegio de saber nuestro idioma y el de sus abuelitos turcos.t Te amo mucho y bendigo siempre, BETTY
I believe it is an inspiring article for young parents that want to have their children to grow knowing their ROOTS and being proud of it. How inportat that is………
Congratulations.
Lovely article Mario. Another advantage you have is the amount of Turkish and Spanish speakers around Aylin.
My children do understand some Turkish, yet we did not have that community for them to progress further. Sometimes it saddens me to know that because we communicate in English, they lack the true understanding of what I try to convey.Each culture has shorthand methods of communicating, so the bedrock of communication is built upon gestures, looks and even biting the lower lip. So many cues are missed in speaking only in English, so the essentials of the words become distorted and only are viewed through a limited lens of comprehension.
To know where we are going, we have to understand where we came from. More than the trilingualism, it is the basis of a parent-child relationship. From what I see, both sides of the family are actively assisting you in your journey.
You’ll do fine, and Aylin will be even more special than she is now. My little laughing rose chose her parents well.
Love
Hala